Echelon indoor cycling bikes have always held a special place in my heart within the world of spin bikes for Zwift and Peloton apps. What sets them apart is their remarkable blend of top-notch quality and affordability. However, when it comes to their saddles, I must admit they don’t quite match the comfort levels I desire.
With the exception of the EX7s model, which boasts extra gel padding, the other Echelon models feature a similar seat design with dimensions of 6 inches in width, 9 inches in length, and 2 inches in depth of foam padding. While these seats may suit some riders, they aren’t universally comfortable. Some individuals, like me, crave a wider seat for enhanced comfort, while others prefer narrower seats with reduced friction for improved performance.
For my own comfort, I initially relied on a padded seat cover and a pair of 3-layer padded shorts to mitigate saddle soreness and discomfort. However, as time passed, I realized that the additional padding from these accessories was affecting my balance and pedal stroke efficiency. So, I made the decision to swap out the Echelon bike seat for one that didn’t require a seat cover.
After dedicating some time to research, I uncovered a selection of replacement seats for Echelon bikes that provided an exceptionally comfortable riding experience. In this article, I’ll be sharing my personal insights and experiences with these replacement seats. It’s important to note that the choice of a comfortable spin bike seat is highly individual, influenced by factors like body shape and riding style. What works for me might not be the perfect fit for you.
Nonetheless, considering the wide variety of Echelon bike replacement seats that I’ve thoroughly reviewed and compared in this article, there’s a strong likelihood that you’ll discover the ideal Echelon indoor bike seat to suit your specific needs. And if, by chance, none of these replacement saddles for Echelon indoor cycling bikes align with your preferences, fear not—you can always opt for a different one, as long as it mounts on a standard 7/8″ (22.2mm) seat clamp. So, without further delay, let’s dive into the top recommendations for the best and most comfortable seats for Echelon exercise bikes that I wholeheartedly endorse.
The Best Saddles for Echelon Indoor Bikes:
Table of Contents
Wittkop 3-Zone Concept Gel Bike Seat: Ultimate Comfort with a Spacious Design
Let’s dive straight into why the Wittkop Comfort Gel Bike Seat is an exceptional choice as a replacement seat for your Echelon indoor bike and one of the best Echelon accessories.
No compatibility issues here! This Wittkop model effortlessly fits both the EX3 and EX15, as well as other Echelon exercise bikes, without a hitch.
While it’s 2 inches wider and 1 inch longer than the stock Echelon seat, don’t let that deter you. With dimensions of 10″L x 8.5″W and 3.8″H, it delivers the essential support your posterior craves.
Inside the box, I found an extra clamp, which I opted to use instead of the Echelon’s original. My advice? Hang on to the original Echelon clamp just in case, but this Wittkop clamp does the job brilliantly.
You don’t need to be a DIY expert to swap out your seat. All you require is a 15mm wrench to loosen the clamp bolt, remove the old seat, and attach the Wittkop seat. It’s that simple!
When you replace the standard Echelon seat on models like the EX15, EX3, EX4, or EX5 with the Wittkop Comfort Gel Bike Seat, you’ll immediately notice a world of difference. This seat boasts a 3-zone concept design, with a curved shape that prevents overheating – a godsend during those long summer rides. It also ensures your sensitive areas don’t get squished against the seat.
Say goodbye to discomfort caused by traditional foam seat cushions. The gel cushion and seamless cover on this Wittkop seat are game-changers. Unlike the original seat cushion, which often left me shifting in pain, this seat lets you focus on your ride, thanks to its ergonomic design.
Worried about sliding around during intense rides? The Wittkop seat features clever patterns on top that keep you firmly in place, allowing you to concentrate on your pedal strokes.
If you’re looking for maximum comfort during a 50-minute indoor cycling class, I’m confident you’ll fall in love with this Echelon stationary bike replacement seat. However, if you prioritize performance and power efficiency, you might prefer a narrower, less padded saddle for your Echelon indoor bike – I’ve listed some options below.
I suggest you upgrade your Echelon indoor bike experience today with the Wittkop Comfort Gel Bike Seat. If you change your bike to a Nordictrack S22i it will still be a good replacement seat there as well – your posterior will thank you!
Wittkop 5-Zone Concept Foam Bike Seat: Comfortable Support with a Sleek Profile
When I first installed the 5-Zone Concept Wittkop seat on my Echelon bike, I couldn’t help but feel a tad disappointed about the extra $10 investment compared to the 3-Zone Concept Wittkop. However, after two weeks of pedaling away on my Echelon spin bike, I started to appreciate the increasing comfort and overall pleasantness it offered.
What sets this Echelon bike replacement saddle apart is its innovative 5-Zone concept. This design not only enhances breathability and minimizes friction, surpassing the 3-Zone concept seat, but it also provides an extra level of grip. While this feature is suitable for regular road cycling, it may be a bit catchier during intense spinning workouts when you’re frequently shifting positions.
Installation is a breeze – all you need is a 13mm wrench to loosen and tighten the seat clamp. While the wrench isn’t included, the seat comes with its own clamp, eliminating the need to use your Echelon bike’s clamp.
When considering this replacement seat for your Echelon stock seat, your riding style should be top of mind. You have three models to choose from, each tailored to a different riding preference. I opted for the Touring model because of my forward-leaning riding style.
If you weigh over 200 lbs and prefer an upright position, the “City” model is likely your best bet. Conversely, if you weigh less and tend to lean forward and rely on the handlebars, the “MTB” model with its compact design and reduced friction is a smart choice.
Quality is evident in all Wittkop seats, featuring 1.5 inches of memory foam and a seamless Skai synthetic leather surface. Although it’s not as plush as the 3-Zone concept Gel seat, it’s waterproof – perfect for outdoor bike adventures.
Now, let’s talk dimensions. Each Wittkop Echelon indoor cycling bike replacement seat varies in size. The MTB model is the longest and narrowest at 11.42″ L, 5.79″ W, and 2.5″ H. Slightly shorter but wider than the MTB is the Touring model at 10.8″L, 6.7″W, and 3.5″H, making it a suitable choice for most Echelon bike owners. Start with this model, and if it doesn’t quite cut it, consider another.
Lastly, the City model is the shortest yet widest of the three Wittkop seats, measuring at 10″L, 8.5″W, and 3.2″H. I recommend the City model if you’re on the heavier side and prefer a more upright riding position when cycling indoors on your Echelon bike.
Regardless of your choice among these comfortable Echelon indoor bike replacement saddles, they all boast a sleek appearance, exceptional comfort, and ingenious built-in springs to minimize spinal impact.
If you ever feel like you’re slipping forward or backward while pedaling, simply loosen the clamp bolt and make adjustments to the angle and placement. Ensure a secure tightening to avoid damaging the threads.
Lastly, it’s worth highlighting the unisex design of these replacement saddles for Echelon bikes. If, like me, you share your Echelon bike with someone of the opposite sex in your household, you both can enhance your Echelon indoor cycling experience with the Wittkop 5-Zone Concept foam bike seat without compromising on comfort.
Xmifer Memory Foam Bike Seat: Comfortable Riding with Improved Breathability
When I decided to try out the Xmifer bike seat on my Echelon EX5, I had some doubts, but after a couple of indoor cycling sessions, I found myself pleasantly surprised. While it may not match the durability of Wittkop Echelon bike replacement saddles, it certainly stands out for its remarkable softness.
Comfort is where the Xmifer seat truly shines, boasting a generous 2.8 inches of memory foam padding. Even if you’re on the heavier side, weighing above 200 lbs, this ample padding ensures a comfortable 45-minute indoor cycling ride.
Although labeled as “oversized,” I’d describe it more as a regular-sized seat, shorter and narrower than the Wittkop City saddle. However, compared to those slender MTB seats, you could indeed call it oversized, measuring at 10.4 inches in length and 8.3 inches in width.
One important detail to note is the seat’s 4.5-inch height from the surface to the bottom where you attach the clamp. For shorter individuals with their bike seats set to the minimum height, this Xmifer seat may add an extra inch or two to the overall saddle height, potentially making the bike slightly too tall for comfort. It’s not a deal-breaker, but it’s worth considering.
In terms of materials, the Xmifer seat sticks to standard components for its price range. Its surface is crafted from microfiber artificial leather. Unfortunately, the pieces are sewn together, unlike the single-piece design of Wittkop saddles.
This stitching approach raises concerns about the seat’s long-term durability compared to Wittkop and Velmia saddles. Although the seams don’t cause hotspots because they are on the edge of the saddle, over time, the seam openings may slightly enlarge, and the fabric underneath could develop minor ripples. While the comfort is there, it may not quite match the quality of top-rated saddles for Echelon exercise bikes.
Another drawback I noticed with this saddle is the absence of a guard to maintain its position when mounted, similar to the one included with the Echelon’s original seat. Without it, the Xmifer seat occasionally tilts downward, requiring you to readjust its position.
While the memory foam cushion is of decent quality, I personally lean towards gel saddles with slightly less padding, as excessive cushioning can reduce power efficiency. However, if you struggle with sciatica nerve issues or have a sensitive bottom and prioritize maximum comfort, this Echelon bike replacement saddle won’t disappoint.
A pleasant surprise with the Xmifer seat is the inclusion of a 13mm and 15mm wrench, an Allen key, and a clamp. Many other comfortable Echelon exercise bike saddles I’ve reviewed in this price range lacked these tools, even though they cost twice as much as the Xmifer. All in all, I believe it’s an excellent choice for beginner indoor cyclists, heavier riders, and individuals dealing with sciatica nerve problems.
Green Memory Foam Bike Seat: Comfort and Value with a Focus on Durability
Undoubtedly, one of the finest replacement seats for Echelon spin bikes is the Green memory foam bike seat. I ordered it for review purposes when I was doing the round up for the best spin bike seats, and the moment I swapped it with the stock Echelon spin bike seat, my body felt the immediate difference. Measuring at 8 inches in width, 9.7 inches in length, and featuring a plush 2.2 inches of memory foam padding, it certainly brings comfort to your ride.
While it may not be the most durable option out there, especially when compared to more premium alternatives, its performance easily surpasses the original Echelon indoor bike seat, considering its attractive price point. The slightly lower durability of its cover is expected, given its affordability, which makes it a cost-effective choice, especially when compared to the Wittkop saddles that cost nearly $40.
One standout feature of this Echelon indoor bike replacement seat is its seamless cover. Unlike some other options like the Xmifer, which have sewn seams that can potentially increase discomfort by causing hotspots, the Green seat eliminates this issue.
Moreover, its surface boasts a grippier texture, thanks to carefully designed patterns that prevent unwanted sliding forward and backward, particularly when you’re sweating during an intense workout.
Additionally, the seat includes a strategically placed airflow hole, which proves invaluable during scorching summer rides. This is a feature notably absent in the Xmifer saddle, and its absence becomes more noticeable during extended rides.
The Green seat is equipped with two well-made suspensions, akin to those found on the Xmifer. These suspensions play a crucial role in minimizing the impact on your spine when you mount and dismount the saddle, which is a common occurrence when following Peloton or Echelon online cycling classes from the comfort of your home.
Upon ordering, the Green seat arrives complete with all the necessary hardware and a wrench for installation. Setting it up is a breeze – I replaced my old seat with the new one in just five minutes. If you prefer, you can utilize the Echelon clamp and keep the one that comes with the seat as a spare.
Additionally, the seat offers the flexibility to be tilted up and down, a significant enhancement for your comfort during rides. Overall, it’s a fantastic seat offering excellent value, though it’s essential to keep its durability in mind over the long term.
Echelon Original Oversized Extra Cushion Bike Seat: By Echelon for Optimal Comfort
I decided to give the Original Echelon Oversized Extra Cushion Bike Seat a try out of sheer curiosity, wanting to see how it compared to replacement seats from other brands. While it indeed provided more support and comfort than the stock Echelon seat that came with my bike, it didn’t quite reach the level of comfort I experienced with Wittkop seats – at least, not for me.
With a width of 9.5 inches, it’s nearly double the width of the original Echelon bike seat, which measures only 5.9 inches across. This generous width offers ample surface area for support and comfort, making it possibly the widest of all the Echelon exercise bike replacement saddles I’ve evaluated.
Although it lacks the airflow design found in some other Echelon replacement seats I reviewed, it compensates with 2.5 inches of gel padding, which adds a significant level of softness and comfort. However, due to its width, I wouldn’t recommend it for prolonged cycling sessions, as the added width may cause some extra friction between your inner thighs and the seat.
While I personally found it comfortable enough not to require a gel cover, Echelon does offer a compatible seat cover for around $20, sharing the same size and dimensions as this saddle for a perfect fit. However, if you’re like me and too much padding can limit your movement and affect performance, you might opt not to add a cover to this well-padded Echelon bike replacement seat.
In terms of installation, it was a breeze, and the build quality is impressive, especially considering the affordable price point. If you have wider hips or carry a bit more weight, I would highly recommend considering this model. It’s equipped to enhance the comfort of your cycling workouts, making it an excellent choice for those seeking an upgrade.
Here are some valuable tips to consider when replacing the saddle on your Echelon indoor bike:
- Seat and Clamp Assembly: Most Echelon indoor bike replacement saddles consist of two parts – a seat and a clamp. Start by attaching the seat to the clamp and then install the clamp onto the seat post.
- Secure Your Seat: If you notice your seat tilting forward or backward during your ride, it’s crucial to address it immediately. Tighten the seat clamp as firmly as possible to prevent potential damage to the thread and the clamp. If the issue persists, consider using the original Echelon clamp for added stability.
- Universal Compatibility: Echelon indoor cycling bikes, including the EX15, Ex1, Ex3, EX4, Ex5, and EX7s, feature a standard bicycle seat mount. This means you can easily swap in a different seat that suits your preferences.
- Size Matters: The original Echelon indoor cycling bike seats typically measure 6 inches in width, 9 inches in length, and have a 1.8-inch depth. If you’re a beginner indoor cyclist and find the stock seat uncomfortable, opt for a replacement seat with at least a 2-inch cushion and an 8-inch width for improved comfort.
- Seat Clamp Compatibility: You can choose any seat clamp you prefer for your Echelon bike, as long as it has a 7/8-inch (22.2mm) inside diameter, ensuring a secure fit.
- Consider Your Height: If you’re on the shorter side and your Echelon seat is already adjusted to its minimum height, think twice about selecting a thick replacement seat like the Green or Xmifer. Thicker seats add extra height to the bike, which may not be ideal for shorter individuals in this scenario.
- Enhance Comfort: Regardless of the seat you choose, achieving true comfort on your Echelon indoor cycling bike often requires the use of padded indoor cycling shorts. These shorts provide additional cushioning for your rides, significantly improving your overall comfort.
- Adjust your saddle: It’s probably the very first thing that you need to do before even changing your seat. Make sure the seat is adjust for your height because if it’s set a little lower or higher, it can cause discomfort.
By following the above and the tips I added in this article, you can ensure a smoother and more comfortable experience when replacing the saddle on your Echelon indoor bike. I also suggest that you read our how to choose a comfortable spin bike seat article because it has several useful tips that will equip you with further knowledge when buying a saddle for your Echelon spin bike.